Dwindling Support: 30th Annual School M&O Cost Study
Apr 1, 2001 12:00 PM, Joe Agron
(EDITOR'S NOTE: This file contains the text of the article. To view or print the charts and graphs contained in the complete Maintenance and Operations report, click here. This links to a PDF file and requires Acrobat Reader.)
As the nation's school buildings grow older and physical conditions continue to deteriorate, the logical solution would be for school districts to concentrate more resources to improve the situation. However, this is not the case for most elementary and secondary institutions. School districts across the nation are dedicating a smaller percentage of available funds to maintaining and operating the facilities that house America's youth.
Spending per student for the 2000-01 school year on maintenance and operations (M&O) by school districts actually increased slightly from last year's survey — up 3 percent. But when taken as a percentage of net current expenditures (NCE), spending dropped to 8.5 percent compared with 9 percent the year before, according to American School & University's 30th annual Maintenance and Operations Cost Study.
Not only is this the fourth consecutive year that schools have allocated a smaller percentage of expenditures to M&O of their facilities, but also the figure is the lowest in three decades.
GETTING THE NUMBERS
In November, a detailed survey was mailed to chief business officials at public school districts with enrollment of more than 600 students. The questionnaire asked administrators to document various M&O costs, including salary/payroll, energy, utilities, maintenance and grounds equipment and supplies, outside contract labor and other costs.
The median number for each category (payroll, gas, electricity, utilities, equipment and supplies, etc.) was identified on a national and regional level. (It's important to note that the number of responses received from each region will directly affect final figures reported from year to year.) Data reported identify budgeted expenditures for M&O per student and per square foot for the 2000-01 school year.
Following are the categories used on the survey questionnaire:
Budgeted: Amounts for the 2000-01 school year, reported as of the December 2000 survey deadline.
Per student: Based on enrollment (average daily attendance as of November 2000).
Per square foot: Based on total gross area of all district buildings maintained, including corridors, offices and common space.
NCE (net current expenditure): Total district expenditures, including teacher salaries, minus the cost of capital outlay, debt service and transportation.
Total maintenance and operations (M&O) expenditures: Including salaries, fringes, overhead, energy, utilities, equipment and supplies, outside contracts, etc., for custodial, maintenance and grounds.
Custodial: Those individuals responsible for building upkeep and cleaning.
Maintenance: Those individuals who perform skilled jobs, such as HVAC, electrical or plumbing repair.
Grounds: Those individuals responsible for landscape upkeep and maintenance.
Payroll: Including fringes.
Average salary: Annualized, excluding fringes.
Outside contract labor: Those hired for specialized jobs to maintain or repair building systems or equipment, such as HVAC maintenance or repair.
Other fuel: Including oil and coal.
Other utilities: Including water, telephone, etc.
Other: Most often identified as clerical costs, trash removal, travel expenses, equipment repair and rental, and insurance.
When comparing your school district's M&O expenditures with the regional and national medians reported, keep in mind that all costs are greatly affected by the age and overall condition of buildings, climate, the labor market in your area, as well as other factors over which school administrators have limited control. Also, the rapid escalation in energy costs experienced by most areas of the country this winter most likely is not reflected in this year's data. This is due to the fact that budgets reported in the survey were already set for most schools prior to the spike in prices.
In addition, because the study uses medians, and the majority of the nation's school districts — and respondents to the survey — are small- to medium-size (median student enrollment of 1,196), costs may vary if you are from a much larger institution.
EXAMINING THE DATA
Among the findings of this year's survey:
The median public school district has nine full-time custodial, three full-time maintenance and two full-time grounds personnel.
The amount of square feet maintained per custodian increased to 22,222 from 21,156 square feet last year. Square feet maintained per maintenance worker dropped to 82,349 from 87,500 square feet last year. Acreage maintained per grounds worker decreased as well, falling to 30 from 41 last year.
Modest salary increases were reported for the three titles surveyed. National median salaries for maintenance and grounds personnel were $29,213 (up five percent from the prior year) and $23,858 (up three percent) respectively. Whereas custodial salaries rose to $22,686, the percentage increase from last year was less than one percent.
It is more expensive to transport students to school this year. The median district spends 4.4 percent of its total budget and $333 per pupil on transportation (4.2 percent and $293 per pupil last year).
THE LOCAL LOOK
School districts in Region 9 and Region 2 continue to report the highest maintenance and operations costs in a variety of categories. Region 9 led the pack in per-student expenditures for other fuel, custodial salaries, and per-square-foot costs for payroll (custodial, maintenance and grounds), outside contract labor, electricity, other utilities, grounds equipment and supplies, and total M&O.
Region 2 reported the highest per-student expenditures for custodial payroll, outside contract labor, transportation, total M&O and total NCE. Districts in the region also had the highest per-square-foot costs for other fuel and total NCE, and maintenance salaries.
Other highs were reported in Region 1 (per-student cost for grounds payroll and square feet covered per maintenance worker), Region 3 (per-student cost for maintenance payroll, per-square-foot cost for other expenses, acres maintained per grounds worker, and transportation cost as a percentage of total district expenditures), Region 5 (grounds salaries), Region 6 (per-student costs for electricity and grounds equipment and supplies, per-square-foot cost for maintenance equipment and supplies, and M&O as a percentage of NCE), Region 7 (per-student cost for other expenses), Region 8 (per-student costs for gas and maintenance equipment and supplies, per-square-foot cost for gas, and square feet maintained per custodial worker), and Region 10 (per-student cost for other utilities).
Some of the lowest expenditures per category were reported in Region 1 (per-square-foot costs for maintenance payroll and ground equipment and supplies), Region 2 (per-square-foot cost for maintenance equipment and supplies), Region 4 (per-student costs for outside contract labor, maintenance and grounds equipment and supplies, other expenses [tied] and total M&O, per-square-foot costs for custodial payroll, outside contract labor and other expenses [tied], and M&O as a percentage of NCE) and Region 5 (per-student costs for maintenance and grounds payroll, other fuel and other expenses [tied], and per-square-foot costs for other fuel and other expenses [tied]).
Other lows were reported in Region 6 (per-student cost for total NCE, and salaries for custodial and grounds personnel), Region 7 (per-student and per-square-foot costs for other utilities, and per-square-foot cost for grounds payroll [tied]), Region 8 (maintenance salaries, and per-square-foot costs for electricity, total M&O, total NCE and grounds payroll [tied]), Region 9 (per-student costs for custodial payroll and transportation, per-student and per-square-foot costs for gas and other expenses [tied], transportation cost as a percentage of total district expenditures, and square feet maintained by custodial, maintenance and grounds personnel) and Region 10 (per-student cost for electricity).
