May 24, 2012


Font Size


         Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines  

Acoustics

Feb 1, 2009 12:00 PM, By Mike Kennedy (mkennedy@asumag.com)

Some schools use amplification to boost a teacher's voice, but acoustics advocates say such systems should be a last resort.

Think back to your teen-age years. You're trying to listen to your new Aerosmith record, but it's hard to hear because your sister is yapping on the phone. The easiest solution? Crank up the stereo volume.

Education institutions use a similar rationale when they install amplification systems in classrooms. In cases where noise from outside the classroom can't be controlled, or where a teacher's voice does not project sufficiently throughout the learning space, schools may opt to use a voice-amplification system.

An instructor is miked for sound, and the increased decibels of the teacher's words being broadcast to students results in a better voice-to-background noise ratio.

But advocates of good classroom acoustics say pumping up the volume is hardly the ideal solution. The teenager turning up the sound on his stereo may be able to hear his music and drown out other noise, but the overall effect is likely to prompt an irritated parent to tell the teen to quit making such a racket. Likewise, the added noise from an amplified voice might make listening uncomfortable for some students.

The position of the Acoustical Society of America (ASA) is that sound amplification should not be used routinely in typical, small mainstream classrooms.

"Sound amplification increases rather than decreases overall sound levels," the ASA says. "Also, unless classroom walls, ceilings and floors are acoustically upgraded to improve their sound insulation, amplified sound may be heard in adjacent classrooms, interfering with learning there."

A 2007 guide produced by the New Zealand Ministry of Education on acoustics in learning spaces lists the pros and cons of systems that amplify a teacher's voice:

  • Advantages: signal-to-sound ratios are improved at the flick of a switch; the teacher can be heard from anywhere in the room; the teacher's voice is less stressed; and students' on-task behavior and comprehension may be improved.

  • Disadvantages: the systems are expensive to install; they need regular maintenance; sound levels must be set correctly to be effective; some teachers don't like them and may not use them; the long-term effects on the development of students' listening skills are, as yet, unknown; and they only assist teacher-to-student communication and are not useful in student-to-teacher or student-to-student communication.


Acceptable Use Policy
blog comments powered by Disqus
Featured Story

Today's School Security

By Mike Kennedy

Improved technology and more effective prevention programs help schools and universities provide safer learning environments.

Contest

Learn more

OSRAM SYLVANIA presents the Great Lighting for Education Challenge

One lucky school will receive a full high-efficiency OCTRONŽ T8 classroom retrofit, including lamps, ballast, controls, fixtures and installation, a value of about $15,000. Learn more!

Spotlight On

Now Accepting Entries: Architectural Portfolio 2012

Entry forms due June 11. Click here for more information. 30th Anniversary Special for multi-page entries!

2012 Calendar of Industry Events

From SchoolDesigns.com and American School & University. Download it now!

AS&U 100

American School & University highlights the largest 100 school districts each September. Who's growing and who's slowing?

AS&U's Online Buyers' Guide

Online Buyers' Guide

Find manufacturers and suppliers of products and services for education facilities, business and operations, including:

More Categories

Back to Top

Browse Back Issues

April 2012 issue of American School and University March 2012 issue of American School and University February 2012 issue of American School and University January 2012 issue of American School and University December 2011 issue of American School and University November 2011 issue of American School and University October 2011 issue of American School and University September 2011 issue of American School and University August 2011 issue of American School and University
BROWSE BACK ISSUES